← All articles
7 min read

Free or Paid VPN: What the Difference and the Risks Are

A free VPN looks like the ideal solution right up to the first question: what, then, does the service earn its money on. Infrastructure costs money — servers, channels, support, the constant upkeep of routes in changing network conditions. If the user is not paying, someone else is, and that someone is usually an advertiser or a buyer of data. Here, without moralizing, is a look at the models that exist, why they are dangerous, and in which scenarios a free option really is suitable.

How Free VPN Services Make Money

There are only a handful of models, and they are well documented. The first is advertising inside the app: banners and video clips paid for by an ad network. The second is the sale of anonymized — and sometimes thoroughly personal — statistics about which sites and apps users open. The third is affiliate programs, where the service inserts its own referral tags into links to shops. The fourth, the most unpleasant, is reselling the channel: the user's device becomes an exit node of someone else's network, and unfamiliar traffic passes through your home address. The fifth model is an honest one — a free plan as a storefront for the paid one, with clear limits and no surprises. The problem is that from the outside all five look identical: a “connect” button and a promise of a fast internet. They can be told apart only by the privacy policy and by whether the company earns anything from subscriptions at all. A useful exercise before installing is to find the pricing page on the service's site. If there is no paid plan at all, then the money is coming from somewhere else, and it is worth finding out where.

Selling Data and Substituting Advertising

A VPN sees roughly what your telecoms operator would see: all of a device's traffic passes through its server. Beyond that the tunnel adds nothing — what changes is the addressee of your trust: instead of the ISP you trust the company running the VPN. A service that earns money on data can collect the history of domains, session times and device characteristics and tie all of it to an advertising identifier. A profile like that is worth money on the market. An appeal to “you accepted the terms at installation” is weak protection: consent to the processing of personal data has to be specific and informed, and a clause buried in a long text does not meet that requirement. Substituting advertising is a category of its own. The contents of an encrypted connection cannot simply be rewritten en route: the app has either to talk you into installing its own root certificate, or to lure you into its built-in browser, where the page is opened by its own means. Both schemes exist, and both are visible at the installation stage — if a client asks you to install a certificate or insistently offers “its own” browser, that is a reason to stop. The worst case is built-in analytics or advertising libraries inside the client itself, which keep sending telemetry even when the connection is switched off. That is exactly why the question of who pays for the server matters more than the question of speed. Verifying this from the user's side is next to impossible: what remains is to read the privacy policy and look at which permissions and certificates the client requests at installation.

Limits on Speed, Traffic and Devices

Even an honest free plan has a ceiling, and it is usually felt immediately. The exact figures differ from service to service, so what you need to look at are the terms of the plan you are taking, but the set of limits repeats itself. The traffic limit is most often a few gigabytes a month, and with video it runs out over a couple of evenings. Speed is frequently throttled artificially to encourage a move to the paid plan: pages open, but a stream in high resolution no longer does. The choice of locations is cut down, and the ones that remain available are as a rule the most overloaded. The number of devices is often limited to one, so the phone and the laptop have to be switched over in turn. Add the support queue, which on a free plan usually simply does not exist, and you get an honest picture: a free VPN solves a one-off task but copes badly with a daily load. On paid plans there are usually more devices, though the figure depends on the plan there too: with us, for instance, 30 devices is the ceiling of the top plan rather than a general rule. A separate annoyance is server congestion in the evening hours: free locations fill up at exactly the time people sit down to watch video. Speed falls during those hours not because of the protocol but because of the number of neighbors on the same channel.

When a Free VPN Really Is Appropriate

A free VPN is suitable for getting to know the service or briefly checking the quality of the connection. Please review the data processing policy and tariff terms before use. For mail, bank and work accounts, it is especially important to trust the service operator.

How a Paid Service Differs

The paid service is funded by subscriptions. This allows you to maintain infrastructure, update applications, respond to users and offer multiple devices in one account. Compare tariff conditions and data processing policies before paying.

How to evaluate the terms of a paid service

Compare tariffs by speed, traffic and number of devices. Read the data policy and check which apps your devices support. You can start with a suitable short-term plan and, if necessary, upgrade to a long-term subscription.

Frequently asked questions

What exactly does a user of a free VPN risk?

The main risks of free VPNs are collecting browsing history, advertising, and using the device as an exit node of someone else’s network. Also check speed limits, traffic limits and the number of available devices.

Are there honest free VPNs?

Yes, when the free plan serves as a storefront for the paid one and the company earns its money from subscriptions. Such services state their limits on traffic, speed and the number of devices openly and do not promise anything unlimited. It is worth checking against a single criterion: is it clear what the company lives on.

Can a free VPN be used for signing in to a bank or email?

It is better not to. All of a device's traffic passes through the VPN server, and a service with an advertising model is technically capable of collecting metadata about your sessions. For signing in to banking, email and work systems, use a connection you pay for and whose policy on logs you can read.

How to choose a paid VPN before subscribing?

Compare tariff terms, data processing policies, list of compatible devices and methods of contacting support. Consider the quality of your Internet connection and available server countries.

Ready for a stable internet connection?